Han Shot First Han vs. Greedo: Who shot first?
"Han shot first" bezieht sich auf eine kontroverse Änderung einer Szene im Science-Fiction-Actionfilm Star Wars, in der Han Solo in der Mos Eisley Cantina mit dem Kopfgeldjäger Greedo konfrontiert wird. In der Originalversion der Szene erschießt. „Han shot first“? in der der Schmuggler Han Solo (Harrison Ford) auf den Kopfgeldjäger Greedo (Paul Blake) trifft: Greedo konfrontiert Solo. Jetzt heizt der Filmemacher die "Han shot first"-Debatte mit einer neuen Erklärung dafür erneut an. , Uhr. Greedo: Who shot first? Doch um was geht es bei der sogenannten»Han shot first«-Diskussion genau? Als Star Wars: Episode 4 - Eine neue. Who shot first? Das ist eine der brennendsten Fragen, die Star Wars-Fans seit Jahrzehnten beschäftigt. Wir erklären euch, wie Solo: A Star.
Beschreibung: Han Shot First T-Shirt. Greedo: "You can tell that to Jabba. He may only take your ship." Han: "Over my dead body." Greedo: "That's the idea. Greedo: Who shot first? Doch um was geht es bei der sogenannten»Han shot first«-Diskussion genau? Als Star Wars: Episode 4 - Eine neue. „Han Shot First!“ ziert seitdem nicht nur Protest-T-Shirts. George Lucas gab über die Jahre unterschiedliche Statements zu der Kontroverse ab.
He is a tough James Dean style starpilot about thirty years old. A mercenary in a starship, simple, sentimental and cocksure of himself.
A lovely young alien girl has her arms around him but the young space rogue sends her bouncing on her way as the group approaches.
He is a burly-bearded but ruggedly handsome boy dressed in a gaudy array of flamboyant apparel. I had seen A New Hope , of course.
It had electrified me exactly like it did everybody else, but the thing that really got me was Harrison Ford. He embodied that spirit.
Han never thinks about it. Accepting the job saw Kasdan inhabiting the role of Han himself; only a simple, sentimental and cocksure rogue would think he could deliver a rousing version of Solo: A Star Wars Story.
And like the hero, who in the prequel flies through turbulent, Lovecraftian hell of the Kessel Run in 12 parsecs, only to deliver the Millennium Falcon dinged and torn to shreds, Kasdan pulls it off without much flair.
Solo: A Star Wars Story makes it to the end credits intact. These may be the wisest words anyone has ever said about Star Wars.
But the scene only became a defining moment through fan chatter. This could really save my neck. That character, not the one who shot first, floats through the original trilogy.
He was just another pirate, and until Luke Skywalker and Ben Kenobi showed up at the Mos Eisley cantina, only waded knee-deep into trouble if there was a credit bonus involved.
He killed Greedo to protect himself and Chewie. Love kept him fighting the Empire alongside Leia. His redemption was an accident.
Whether the character exists without Harrison Ford in the role is another question entirely, and likely depends on when and how you saw Star Wars.
Solo: A Star Wars Story draws a calibrated line between the past and what we know to be true. First love is hard — especially when a old water worm dame is demanding results from your thievery.
Instead, Han will always rise to the occasion for those in need of a foolhardy gunslinger on a life-or-death mission.
Or was it established on the spice mines of Kessel? The surly shell that shows its face and pulls a gun in the Mos Eisley cantina?
An act. When handed the keys to the Falcon, like so many EU writers and clever gamemakers of the past, he feels compelled to right the Lucas wrongs — for the fans.
Before the aging smuggler can deliver a spiel on how the world really works, Han shoots first. That one was for Aurra Sing!
There are generations of people who see the movie and only learn later that Han Shot First. On my early morning scrub-through, it looks like the timing has been adjusted farther and they now shoot on the same frame.
But in changing the scene, Lucas has only continued to call attention to the meme. It de-mythologizes the grand myth of Star Wars , turns it into just a thing that people made up and then kept tweaking.
It helps you recognize that it could have been made other ways. It makes you think about story and character building in a way you might not otherwise.
One of the reasons I love Star Wars fandom — and really, any fandom — is that we chose to make this our myth.
Knowing that the myth itself involves choices we can disagree about keeps that myth from becoming religion.
It keeps the myth vibrant and alive. Most of all, staying aware of those choices makes that myth ours.
The gold , space gray , and silver models are each available with the discount. Vox Media has affiliate partnerships.
These do not influence editorial content, though Vox Media may earn commissions for products purchased via affiliate links.
Prices displayed are based on the MSRP at time of posting. You may think this is a simple answer and in some ways it is, but in other ways there are so many, many little details that might matter.
Some time ago this newsletter featured an essay expressing hope that Disney would nail the technical side of its streaming service thanks to the high stakes and the bona fides of BAMtech, the streaming company Disney bought.
I am here for this: putting more Western into the Space Western. Chaim Gartenberg reviews:. The heavily Western mood does suggest that Disney is learning from its blockbuster Marvel franchise, which has seen massive success by dropping the MCU formula and characters into different genres.
Much like how Captain America: The Winter Soldier is designed in the vein of classic spy films or the Ant-Man films are modeled after superheroic heists, The Mandalorian wears its influences proudly.
Good analysis from Julia Alexander. You know that moment when you learn that there are multiple levels of infinity in math and you struggle to wrap your head around it and at some point you think you have it but it slips away?
In context, this makes perfect sense and seems reasonable. But imagine Emperor Palpatine saying it in another context.
That is, I think, actually very smart for this kind of product:. There are 10 of these depth perception effects available at launch — adding disco lights that bend as they hit your body; big red hearts that pop as you move through them, and so on.
Ashley Carman gets into the biggest trend in podcasting. I found this part fascinating:.
Han Shot First - Wie nimmt Solo: A Star Wars Story Bezug auf Han shot first?Möchtest Du mehr Details wissen oder widersprechen? Und ich habe gesagt: Ja, er sollte John Wayne sein. Pfeil nach links. Hier geht es zurück. Etwa die Nummer mit dem Huhn und dem Ei. Bitte beachte unsere Richtlinien zum Erstellen von Kommentaren. Denn der tödliche Showdown zwischen dem Schmuggler und dem Kopfgeldjäger in Episode 4: Eine neue Hoffnung wurde jetzt ein viertes Mal verändert.
JEANNE DARC ANIME Dnemark schickt mit "The Rain" jetzt seine ganz here Version durch Kuba und im Raketentransportzug durch Russland - James Bond Ehemann von Clara Reuter: Thomas. Han Shot First
|TANER||Darunter fällt ein Zuschlag von 3 EUR an. Regression Deutsch die ursprüngliche Szene unterstreicht gerade den moralisch zwiespältigen Charakter von Han Solo und verdeutlicht seine spätere Wandlung https://bitcoinsouth.co/filme-stream-legal/jeffrey-dahmer-apartment.php Antihelden zum Helden. Kleidung anzeigen Lootbox. May click m x a be with you T-Shirt. Link hätte immer zuerst geschossen, man hätte es in click ursprünglichen Nahaufnahme nur nicht gesehen.|
|PAULUSBLICK WORMS||Nun spricht Greedo. Top Kommentare. Und ich habe Star Wars Die Letzten Jedi Movie4k Ja, er sollte John Wayne sein. Dies kann folgende Ursachen haben: 1. Mehr lesen über Pfeil nach links.|
|Virtual Nightmare вЂ“ Open Your Eyes||Fuck You Goethe 2 Online Stream|
|Han Shot First||Quantico Episodenguide|
Even so, the one thing we can say for certain is, the scene now makes even less sense. Almost like a war cry or an insult.
But then, they end up shooting at the same time anyway. However, in a way, it does tie further into the retroactive canonization that Greedo has just always been kind of really bad at his choice of career.
We could go on and on talking about this. If anything, it makes the once-great scene that became a joke, now an actually funny joke.
The A. Movies Star Wars. Germain Lussier. This article needs appropriate citations. Help us improve this article by referencing valid resource material.
Remove this notice when finished. George Lucas wearing a "Han shot first" T-shirt. To say " Han shot first " is to refer, often with distaste, to George Lucas 's changes to the original trilogy.
Often cited by film purists , this phrase more specifically refers to a change made to the A New Hope Special Edition , in the scene involving the characters Han Solo and Greedo in the cantina.
In the original version, after Greedo says, "I've been looking forward to this moment for a long time," Han replies, "Yes, I bet you have" and shoots Greedo under the table while Greedo is pointing a blaster at him.
Thus, Han didn't merely shoot first; he was the only one who fired. In the Special Edition, Greedo shoots at Han and misses, without explanation, from point-blank range, and then Han shoots him.
Later, it was altered again to have Han and Greedo shooting at almost the same time though Greedo still shoots first , with Han dodging out of the way of Greedo's shot.
With such a short time between each shot, it could be assumed that Han was already planning to shoot Greedo, rather than reacting to Greedo's shot.
The principal objection from critics seems to be that the change dilutes and compromises Han's rebellious and ruthless nature.
The change is felt to detract from Han's antiheroic qualities, and diminishes the character's growth and development over the story from a Machiavellian smuggler who cares only about himself and his co-pilot Chewbacca into a committed member of the Rebel Alliance fighting to bring freedom to the galaxy, as his shot is clearly in self-defense.
A secondary objection considers the improbability that Greedo would miss at that range if he fired deliberately.
Thus, his gun must have discharged accidentally, a rather unromantic death. This retroactive sanitizing was loosely paralleled in a DVD version of E.
Although fan criticism of "Greedo shot first" is generally considered to be a legitimate point of view, the incident also provided early inspiration and ongoing ammunition for those who engage in verbal attacks on George Lucas, a practice known as "Lucas bashing.
Suddenly the slimy alien disappears in a blinding flash of light. Han pulls his smoking gun from beneath the table as the other patrons look on in bemused amazement.
Han gets up and starts out of the cantina, flipping the bartender some coins as he leaves. The March 15 version of the script is identical in this scene except that Greedo is referred to simply as "Alien.
In the novelization , this scene is vague. The book only says that "light and noise filled the little corner of the cantina"; it never specifies who shot first.
Greedo spoke Basic in the second issue of Marvel's comic adaptation. Han fired after Greedo threatened to kill him, but before Greedo could finish his next sentence.
One of the deleted scenes included in this CD-ROM is an alternate take of the cantina sequence, including the encounter between Greedo and Han.
It is a black-and-white work print that lacks any added music or sound effects. Greedo speaks English with a Received Pronunciation accent, speaking his original lines as in the script.
Han shoots him before he can fire a shot. Behind the Magic plays this earlier cantina sequence side by side for comparison with the modified "Special Edition" version of the same scene from , making it clear that Greedo shooting was added later.
A New Hope: The Princess, the Scoundrel, and the Farm Boy contains the first retelling of this scene released following the decision to discontinue the Expanded Universe in favor of a new canon continuity.
As described in the novel, Solo reaches for his blaster and slides it from the holster under the table as he is telling Greedo that he doesn't have the money with him.
When Solo states "Over my dead body! I've been looking forward to killing you for a long time. I'll bet you have. The thump as Greedo's body slumped onto the table made the other cantina patrons look over.
However, Star Wars: The Original Trilogy — A Graphic Novel , a graphic novelization of the films, depicts the scene as it's presented in the DVD version, with the two characters shooting at approximately the same time and Greedo's shot missing far wide and up.
Greedo is at no point said to have fired or even considered firing a weapon, and it is said that the last thing he saw was a flash of bright light and his last memory was of bitter injustice.
When asked if this depiction made Episode IV's theatrical version the canonical version of the film, however, Lucasfilm Story Group 's Matt Martin reiterated that the canon one is the revised version, as the nature of book included making various contradictions.